News Haiku: Dave Sires Approaches the Vote with Iowa Common Sense, asking “Why Now?”
Taxpayer money.
Kim wants to rush it through now.
Russia questions wait.
What happened?
Republican state Sen. Dave Sires of Cedar Falls says he will vote no on the steel-mill incentive legislation when lawmakers meet in special session today.
Does he oppose the steel mill?
No. Sires says he supports bringing new investment, jobs and opportunity to Iowa. His objection is to the process.
What’s the problem?
The $15 billion project was announced Monday. By Friday, legislators are being asked to act on a state incentive package potentially worth $1.36 billion over ten years. The package includes a $1.145 billion investment tax credit, $154.35 million in sales-tax refunds and a $60.5 million withholding-tax credit. A local property-tax exemption remains to be determined.
What does Sires want?
More time for legislators to examine the proposal, more answers about the deal and a meaningful opportunity for Iowans to weigh in.
His point?
“But the process also matters.” Sires said there has been too little time for public input and too little opportunity to examine a commitment of this magnitude.
Why does it matter?
Supporting economic development and demanding due diligence aren’t contradictory positions. A project involving potentially $1.36 billion in state incentives deserves scrutiny proportional to the commitment being made.
That last sentence is where I think the piece should end. It captures Sires’ argument without turning the Haiku into either an endorsement of his vote or an argument against the steel mill.
News Haiku
News Haiku is Iowa411 news in miniature.
Each short read begins with a three-line haiku capturing the heart of the story, followed by just enough context to explain what happened, why it matters, and what Iowans should know.
It’s the news, without the novel.
Iowa Farmers Sue USDA Over Canceled Solar Funding
Lawsuit Alleges that USDA Violated Federal Law by Applying New Restrictions to Projects Iowa farmers invested in solar projects expecting federal assistance. Then USDA changed the rules. Now they want a court to make the government honor its commitments.Iowa...
Fool Us Once, Mr. President, Shame On You
Fool Us 13 Times, Shame on UsThere’s an old saying: Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Add 11 more times Iowans were fooled by Donald Trump, and you have the latest Trump promise of the world's biggest steel mill that many feel is nothing more...
Before Iowa Bets On a Steel Mill, First Think About Foxconn
The Proposed Iowa Steel Mill: Lessons from Wisconsin’s Foxconn FailureWisconsin's failed $10 billion manufacturing promise offers lessons as Iowa considers incentives for a proposed $15 billion steel mill.A Wisconsin reader's letter to the Des Moines Register this...
The $1.5 Billion Question: Why the Rush to Subsidize?
Reynolds’ Timing to Dedicate Taxpayer Funds for the Mesabi Steel Mill Is QuestionedTrump's commerce secretary says the deal is done. So why are Iowa lawmakers being called back to offer hundreds of millions more in tax incentives?Iowa's proposed $15 billion steel mill...
The Hook: How Trump Benefits from False Claims
The Trump Tactic for Avoiding Questions about His Big LiesThe $15 billion Iowa steel mill may become everything Trump says it will. But his announcement illustrates a political technique Iowans have seen before: make the promise enormous, collect the political benefit...
Trump Announces $15 Billion Steel Mill for Southeast Iowa
Suspicions raised due to lack of details, timing of announcementThe massive project could bring thousands of jobs and make Iowa a major U.S. steel producer. But production isn't expected until 2030, and important questions about financing, incentives, environmental...
Iowa Legislators at Odds Over the Iran War
Hinson Calls for End to Iran War as Grassley and Ernst Vote to Continue ItIowa Republican Rep. Ashley Hinson is now calling for an “immediate end” to the nearly seven-month Iran war, even as Iowa Republican Sens. Chuck Grassley and Joni Ernst voted Thursday against a...